Cachly vs Geocaching® App: A Comparison Review

With the end of the Geocaching Classic app fast approaching (it’s due to be retired on March 23rd), the question of which app is the best option for iOS users is a hot topic right now. I reviewed the Cachly app in April 2016, but since, then there have been lots of improvements made to this already great app. At the same time, the Geocaching® App has been built upon by Groundspeak, with some much needed features added.

Cachly was launched in December 2015 as a response to developer Nic Hubbard’s disappointment with the capabilities of geocaching apps available to iOS users. In May 2016, Groundspeak announced the renaming of the Geocaching Intro App to the Geocaching® App, and their intention to retire the Geocaching Classic app in September 2016. This date was pushed out to bring more much-wanted features in to the Geocaching® App but the definite end date for Geocaching Classic is now just around the corner.

Cachly vs Geocachingn App: A Comparison Review

To help you decide which app is for you, I have put together a comparison of features. It’s up to you determine which interface appeals more and what functions you absolutely must have, or even just quite like having while you’re caching!

1. Cost

A simple comparison here: Cachly costs $4.99/£4.99/€4.99 to buy at the App Store while the Geocaching® App is free. However, both apps have specific limitations for basic users, so for optimal use, a premium membership to geocaching.com is required. I know cost is a factor for some people to consider, so I wanted to mention it but not dwell on it, because I think when you see the pros and cons of both apps, you can make an informed decision based on your needs. If you’re going to use Cachly every week, five dollars/pounds/Euros is not really a big deal.

Conclusion: On the premise that free is better than not free, the Geocaching® App edges it here.

2. Offline Maps

It felt like a long time coming but the Geocaching® App finally has offline mapping capabilities. This was the major issue that users talked about repeatedly, and actually prevented most people from switching from the Geocaching Classic app. Of course, Cachly had this function almost from day dot and the app also gives you the option to download ‘lite’, more basic data, as well as choosing not to download all cache images, saving on time if you’re in a hurry and also on space, which is very useful if your phone storage is chockablock. Cachly also gives you the option to download vector maps to get an entire state or country map saved on your device.

Conclusion: With more options when saving to offline, Cachly is ahead

3. Route to Cache

Both apps have the ability to start navigating to the cache using various mapping apps like Apple MapsGoogle Maps and Waze, though Cachly is compatible with many more mapping apps. This very nifty feature is intuitive to use in both. I absolutely love this function and use it all the time!

Conclusion: For more navigation app choices, Cachly is slightly ahead 

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

4. Translate

Cachly has a translate function which links to Google Translate from within the cache description, hint and logs. This means less time spent before a trip copying and pasting cache descriptions, hints and logs. It really is an invaluable feature if you’re planning to cache somewhere outside your native language zone. The Geocaching® App does not currently offer translations

Conclusion: Cachly is definitely ahead when it comes to language issues

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

5. Sorting

Both apps have the ability to sort by specific criteria, however Cachly can sort by thirteen different parameters, while the Geocaching® App only has three. With both apps you can sort by distance, favourite points and geocache name. Cachly gives the additional options to sort by cache type, container size, placed date, last found date, difficulty rating, found date, GC code, whether it’s a premium member cache or not, terrain rating and trackable count.

Conclusion: Cachly has a lot more to offer in terms of sorting search results

6. Souvenirs 

With Cachly, you can view all your souvenirs earned; the Geocaching® App does not currently have this functionality.

Conclusion: With the Geocaching® App yet to introduce souvenirs, Cachly has this in the bag

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

7. Message Centre

This was one feature of the new Geocaching® App that users were overwhelmingly positive about. It’s similar to a messenger app like Facebook messenger and a lot easier to navigate around on your phone, compared to the alternative of using a browser. Cachly does not have currently have a message centre feature on the app (it’s not a feature that Groundspeak have extended to third parties to use).

Conclusion: Geocaching® App is the definite champion here

 8. Advanced Search and Filters

The Geocaching® App will allow you to search by location, GC code, trackable code or GeoTour and also gives you the capability to filter by my finds, my geocaches, cache types, container size, as well as every possible difficulty and terrain combination.

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

Cachly has all of the above search options, excluding a search by GeoTour. However, it has the function to filter out inactive, archived, premium and ignored caches. It also allows you to filter to caches where you have corrected the coordinates.

Conclusion: Cachly is far ahead in terms of search and filter options

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

9. Log Images

If you are logging using your phone and want to upload images, the Geocaching® App restricts you to one image per log, so you’ll have to go the website to upload additional images. Cachly allows you to upload multiple images with your log.

Conclusion: The ability to upload multiple log images gives Cachly the advantage 

10. DNF icon

Something arguably quite trivial but very well-liked is the blue frowning face on the Cachly app, denoting a DNF. It is very handy to see at a glance which caches you have tried and failed to find on a previous occasion, particularly if you’re geocaching in an area you are not regularly in. The map on the Geocaching® App doesn’t currently differentiate between caches you’ve previously DNFed, and caches you have not yet looked for.

Conclusion: Cachly has turned my frown upside down with the inclusion of this emoticon

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

11. Bookmark Lists

Both apps show all your saved bookmark lists and both allow you to easily download an entire list for offline use. You can also add caches to any of your bookmark lists from within both apps.

Conclusion: The two apps make it easy to utilise bookmark lists 

12. Map Options

Cachly has quite a number of map options to choose from, so you’ll really be spoiled for choice! The app has Apple Maps, Google Maps, OS maps, Open Maps, Thunderforest and ArcGIS. With the Geocaching® App, you can get Apple Maps and trail maps, which are the maps available offline.

Conclusion: If you like lots of map options, Cachly edges ahead here

13. Basic Membership Restrictions

Since Cachly is an official live API Partner of Groundspeak, there are limitations to what basic members can access via the app. Viewing of full geocache details is limited to just three caches per day. Searches are limited to traditional and event caches only, however, basic members can view other cache types provided they have the GC code, although there is still a limit to three a day.

The Geocaching® App also restricts basic members in relation to cache types, as well as DT ratings, and there is no enhanced filtering or searching which the Cachly app still allows for basic members.

Conclusion: Both apps restrict basic members, so premium membership is a huge advantage to get the most out of both

14. Pending Logs

The Geocaching® App will only save a log as pending if it can’t connect to the internet; otherwise, it will send immediately and without an option to log your trackables as ‘visited’ or to change the date you found the cache. The app allows you to log a find, DNF or to write a note.

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

Cachly, on the other hand, gives you the option to change the find date and to save the log locally to send later on. You can also drop/visit trackables when sending your logs, as well as encrypt your log, should you wish. With Cachly, you can log needs maintenance or needs archived; something the Geocaching® App doesn’t currently offer. Both apps give you the option to add a favourite point as you’re logging.

Conclusion: Cachly gives the user more options and edges ahead

Cachly vs

15. Log Templates and Keywords

Cachly gives you the option to save a log template which will automatically appear when you go to log a cache. This is a nice way of appending a ‘signature’ of sorts to each log that you write. Additionally, you can insert keywords like the cache name or the time you’re logging at automatically while you’re logging. The Geocaching® App does not currently have this functionality.

Conclusion: This unique feature gives Cachly an advantage

16. Pocket Queries

Pocket Queries (PQs) can be accessed via both apps: Cachly shows them under a separate menu in the ‘more’ section, while the Geocaching® App combines PQs with bookmark lists under the ‘lists’ tab.

Conclusion: PQs may be accessed in different ways on each app, but both functionality is intuitive and useful 

17. Import/Export GPX files

Cachly has the capability to import GPX files from iTunes, Dropbox or email. This is a great feature if you’re at an event with as yet unpublished caches and you’re not using a GPSr. The GPX file can be emailed to you and you can import it to Cachly! The Geocaching® App does not currently support this.

Conclusion: Cachly has the advantage on this

18. Attributes

Cachly lists all attributes for each cache, while the Geocaching® App doesn’t have this functionality at present.

Conclusion: Cachly edges ahead here too 

Cachly vs Geocaching App: A Comparison Review

The Verdict

When Cachly and the Geocaching App are considered side-by-side, it’s easy to see how far ahead Cachly is in terms of what you can do with the app. There are features to both apps that I really like: having the Message Centre in mobile format is a big plus for the Geocaching® App, but Cachly‘s more extensive functions are very attractive. For now, I use both apps for various things and this seems to work for me.

What app do you use? What features are the most important to you? Let me know in the comments!

Happy Caching!

Sarah 

© 2017 | Sarah Murphy | All Rights Reserved

*I have not received compensation from any app developer for this review. All views are my own and impartial.


41 thoughts on “Cachly vs Geocaching® App: A Comparison Review

  1. Cachly offers many more options for routing to a cache over the official app. I exclusively use Waze and that’s fully supported by Cachly and not supported by the official app. Same for TomTom and many others.

    The message center is “closed” functionality and not open to any 3rd party app, so though it’s a “feature” you can compare, it’s not an option for anyone else to have. It’s the only reason I have the official app loaded so I can get the message alerts or help someone with a question. Otherwise there’s no reason to have the official app loaded on an iPhone if you run Cachly.

    Like

  2. One thing you didn’t mention is that Cachly has the option to show the 528 foot radius for the caches. I like hiding caches in a city that is pretty concentrated already so this is helpful for me.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Can we get a Cachly vs Looking4Cache comparison? I’ve used L4C for three years now and while I’ve tried Cachly a few times, L4C still seems (in my mind) to be better.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hey Nate! Sure, that’s something I can look at but I won’t be able to post it for a week or two. Follow the blog or my Facebook/Twitter to see it when I publish! Thanks for the suggestion 🙂

      Like

  4. I use the Saved List function in the classic app which is to be canceled. While the new app shows Lists it does not include those I have in the app to be canceled. Also I enter Personal Notes for most caches I seek if found or dnf. I cannot find those Personal Notes in the new app. Please advise what items are not being carried over from the old to the new Groundspeak apps.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Edwin, I don’t actually have any insider information on the app. However, it appears that for now at least the new app doesn’t have a personal note field. Perhaps this is something they will add going forward.

      Like

    2. Edwin the saved lists on the old classic app are only stored on your phone. That old app doesn’t send that data to the website and has no way of exporting the data. This means that there is no way for Cachly, or anything else for that matter, to access those lists. Thus you will need to manually re-create those lists on a new app regardless of what new app you use.

      Personal notes stored on the website show up under Cache Notes in a cache in Cachly. The are synchronised with the website so you can update them in the website and they update in Cachly or you can update in Cachly and they will update on the website.

      Like

  5. It’s amazing that Groundspeak is either unable, or unwilling, to provide the features that are provided by third party developers. I’ve since moved from the classic app to Cachly, but I feel like I should have done it a while ago!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. A couple of things I like in Cachly are the ease of logging favorites and TB’s. Seems like when I switch back to geocaching, I have to hunt for the favorite and give up. Those are minor things I guess but still seem worth mentioning. Thanks for the article.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Do uuu mean how many favourites a cache has or adding a favourite to a cache? I think both these things have actually recently improved in the GC app. However it seems to be the general consensus that Cachly is more user friendly 🙂 thanks for your comment!

      Like

  7. Thank you this is a great comparison. I usually use a GPS but use a phone for occasional caching and looking up info at home and have found cachly very easy to use and as good as the discontinued classic app.

    I have noticed a few additional features not mentioned in the article which are also very handy in the cachly app.

    1. Corrected coordinates- cachly shows any caches that have been corrected via the pencil icon on the website in the actual position on the map. They can also be corrected via the app and saved. This is not available on Geocaching app.

    2. Cache radius can be added on cachly – this is very useful when setting and placing caches. Not available on Geocaching app

    3. Distance can be set to metric or imperial on cachly but Geocaching is set to default with no option to change.

    4. User notes entered on the website can be viewed, edited or added on cachly. Not available on Geocaching.

    5. Zoomed map view – on cachly individual icon will be seen but Geocaching bunches them together in a numbered circle and they can only be viewed when zooming in.

    Like

  8. This is a thorough, well-thought out and researched product review! It helped me to make a decision. Thank you! I think we shall be friends now. 🙂
    The Randimal
    Augusta, Kansas, USA

    Like

  9. Hi
    Must say thanks for this. I have now bought cachly and L4C in advance of the app retiring but was offered a “free” cachly possibly over a year ago, yet on first look was so disappointed I deleted and declined to retry. However as you have highlighted they have clearly made huge improvements to it.

    Still only glancing prior to this and unsure still which to make my next #1 you have highlighted things I will love yet had no idea of namely the 160m circles. Brilliant.

    I look forward to your Cachly vs L4C.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. After reading this helpful comparison I am leaning towards Cachly. However I am feeling a bit miserly about having to pay given I paid for the GC App. I think Groundspeak should buy my new Cachly app….hohoho

    Liked by 1 person

    1. 🙂 that sounds like a pipe dream to me! Seriously though, the one off payment will be well worth it in the end. Cachly is great now, but it only continues to get better and better!

      Like

    2. One of the great things about Cachly is the developer is very responsive and helpful. Not sure why you’d want Groundspeak, who are notorious for not listening to the opinions of their customers, to buy the app. Surely that would be a huge backward step? 🙂

      Like

      1. I think what ‘Jules’ meant to say was, Groundspeak should purchase the Cachly app for him, in lieu of a refund for the paid Classic app. At least that’s how I interpreted it.

        Liked by 1 person

  11. Thank you for the in-depth review; very helpful since Cachly doesn’t have a “lite” version to try. GeoBucket, another Live API partner app, is my main iOS app, which may have a steeper learning curve but looks like it still does a few more things than Cachly, like filtering cache list/map based on attributes, and has a crazy amount of information density on the map. Choice is good!

    Slight correction: According to Groundspeak, the official app does allow Needs Maintenance/Archived logs:

    “As of our last release, the app supports Needs Maintenance and Needs Archived logs through the Report a Problem option accessible in the menu at the top right of a cache’s details.”

    Liked by 1 person

  12. I’ve tried Cachly as I have been using the classic app for 3 years. I do find the offline maps a bit hit and miss, they seem to take a while to appear even when saved offline. Am I doing something wrong ?

    Like

  13. The classic app which I’ve been using for almost 5 years is being replaced by a diminished version (in my opinion), so I’ve been searching for a replacement. Since Cachly addresses several of what I considered to be shortcomings in the classic app while retaining desired features I would be losing in the new Geocaching App, the choice is clear: I’m getting Cachly!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Both apps are being improved regularly but Cachly developers move at a much faster pace! Hope you enjoy using Cachly, I’ve been weaning myself off the Classic app and am now a full time Cachly user 🙂

      Like

  14. Thank you very much for a great review. I’m one of the many disappointed users of the new Groundspeak app that relied on the “classic” app for years. This comparison made it clear: 5 euros for Cachly is a real bargain.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s